I gave it an 8.

I'm going to add a few 8s, though. Like Pan's Labyrinth and The Princess Bride.

And Army of Darkness. Yeah, I'll throw in Drive, too. So I just made them all 9s.

updated, fwiw...

1. Stalker
2. The Mirror
3. I Am Twenty
4. Nostalghia
5. Piebald Dog Running Along the Shore
6. Solaris
7. Life Is Beautiful
8. Andrei Rublev
9. Tale of Tales (animation)
10. Color of Pomegranates
11. My Friend Ivan Lapshin
12. Beyond the Clouds
13. Amelie
14. Decalogue I
15. Shawshank Redemption
16. 12
17. Big Blue
18. Red Balloon
19. Hiroshima Mon Amour
20. WALL*E (animation)
21. There Once Lived a Dog (animation)
22. Blind Chance
23. Mimino
24. Dead Poets Society
25. Winnie the Pooh (animation)
HM: The Apartment, The Island, The Ascent, Moscow on the Hudson

Revision:

1. Wong Kar-Wai - 2046
2. Robert Altman - Nashville
3. Wong Kar-Wai - In the Mood for Love
4. Wes Anderson - Moonrise Kingdom
5. Paul Thomas Anderson - Magnolia
6. Woody Allen - Manhattan
7. Martin Scorsese - Taxi Driver
8. Robert Altman - Short Cuts
9. Ridley Scott - Blade Runner
10. Terrence Malick - The Tree of Life

11. Sofia Coppola - Lost in Translation
12. Hayao Miyazaki - Spirited Away
13. Jean Renoir - The Rules of the Game
14. Vittorio de Sica - Bicycle Thieves
15. Robert Altman - A Prairie Home Companion
16. Billy Wilder - The Apartment
17. Akira Kurosawa - Seven Samurai
18. Harold Ramis - Groundhog Day
19. Francis Ford Coppola - Apocalypse Now
20. Makoto Shinkai - 5 Centimeters per Second

21. Joel and Ethan Coen - The Big Lebowski
22. Edgar Wright - Shaun of the Dead
23. Joel and Ethan Coen - Fargo
24. Quentin Tarantino - Pulp Fiction
25. Sidney Lumet - Network

Still working on 26-50. Ordering's all messed up.

Damn, I can't believe 'The Big Lebowski' is our highest rated Coen Bros. film. Sure, the film is fun and well-made, but I don't get why DDDers put it over masterpieces like 'Fargo' or 'No Country for Old Men'.

I have to add Spirited Away, too. Maybe Princess Mononoke as well.

Only listing live-action because my list would be too big if I also included my favourite animated films.

1. 12 Angry Men
2. The Godfather Parrts 1 & 2
3. Stand By Me
4. 2001: A Space Odyssey
5. The Shawshank Redemption
6. Terminator 2: Judgement Day
7. Amadeus
8. Fight Club
9. American Psycho
10. Pulp Fiction
11. Trainspotting
12. Magnolia
13. Blazing Saddles
14. Drive
15. Apocalypse Now
16. The FIfth Element
17. Layer Cake
18. LA Confidential
19. Leon
20. There Will Be Blood
21. Chinatown
22. Collateral
23. The Prestige
24. The Dark Knight
25. The Green Mile
26. Alien
27. Blade Runner
28. Inception
29. Moon
39. Casino
31. Network
32. 3:10 to Yuma
33. Big Trouble In Little China
34. American Beauty
35. 28 Days Later
36. Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind
37. The Truman Show
38. The LOTR Trilogy
39. District 9
40. Showdown In Little Tokyo

I think Lebowski is as good as those, and has more replay value as well.

Yeah I've seen all 3 near enough the same amount but the one I'd always rather watch is The Big Lebowski.

It's easily my favourite Coen film. Better than Fargo and much better than No Country For Old Men imo.

While Fargo is probably the better-made film, I like Lebowski more because I can relate to it more. It's one of those films you can just watch and enjoy.

Why is Fargo more well-made than The Big Lebowski?

Yeah I never understand that criticism. In what sense is The Big Lebowski not as well made? The editing? The lighting?