Search found 10 matches

nope

I'll take the opinion of the Clash, Pistols, Ramones and MC5 over yours.

if the who count then the rolling stones have to count.

No way, The Who's early singles and live persona are way closer to punk than the Stones ever got.

This is interesting. I like the lists I've seen so far.

The Clash for their expansions of the punk rock form to include elements of reggae and dub.

Guitar smashing is super punk

Okay, so it's considered Punk because of who made it and the cover photo. Not because of the music.

I am confused on how it couldn't be Punk because it was a huge influence on Punk and it is classified as Punk by every critic and everyone in the musical community.

Well, I did say I was letting you ...

Uh..... London Calling?... Clampdown?... Brand New Cadillac.?

Even the hard rock songs, like "Clampdown" and "Death or Glory", are too complex, too sophisticated and too well-produced to be Punk.

Why not?

Well, let's see, the first reason would be that there aren't any punk rock songs on it.

I have a secret to share with all of you...

Lean closer.

Ready?

London Calling isn't a Punk album.

I see the criteria as something like
Influence,Originality,Musical Impact and popularity as a tiebreaker

shut the fuck up.what does fucking have to do with this?

That's so bad.