No! No it fucking doesn't! Why am I seeing daily posts comparing albums consagrated as the best by the best artists ever with newer stuff just because they are so high on an unofficial and incomplete AM list?? With an album that just spent three non-consecutive weeks at #1, which is its best criterion, and is being included within the greatest albums of all time!! And I "may have a point" with BLUE LINES, top tier in acclaim and the first trip hop album!!Fido wrote: Mon Mar 23, 2026 6:12 amClearly way more popular than any of those four, holds up with Freak Out and Ray of Light in acclaim while Darkness on the Edge of Town doesn't exactly strike me as all that influential either. With Blue Lines you may have a point.
I don't want to shit on anybody's contributions, I think the movie lists are great, the yearly 2010s songs are great and a necessary improvement over Lew's ones, and with a dead forum almost any activity is appreciated, but I have to ask just what is the point of this? This can be considered one of the main lists of the site, and we made it as a compromise with other posters, some of them the most knowledgeable of certain eras, taking into account the other decade and subgenre lists and we agreed on the one posted, even if it's not perfect (how could it be?). Now, not even five years have passed, absolutely no new album is being considered, but since half of the people are not posting you can make huge changes that nobody agrees with. All the albums being added were already considered when we made the list, they were already high up on their decade lists, and we agreed they shouldn't be on this one. No, placing them slightly lower than you would because I complain is not a compromise, the main list IS the compromise. No, Beyoncé between ItCotCK and This Year's Model (THIS YEAR'S MODEL, one of the essential albums of new wave and considered a masterpiece for half a century!!) is not a fucking compromise. It's a super popular album released by an already super popular artist that has minimal influence, placing it at #193 IS the compromise. Ryan has it at #71 on the decade list! Don't we respect his work?
Anyway, rant over. I don't write it in bad faith, it's just exhausting having to discuss already discussed points in already discussed lists.
[/quote]
When I said you 'may have a point' I was more or less agreeing with you.
Beyonce was hugely influential on the distribution and promotion of music, which should count as well, for the same reason you'd credit Blonde on Blonde for popularizing the double album.
We could probably chill on some, or even most, of the suggested changes, but this is one of the ones I am actually more adamant about