Greatest Rock Saxophonists (Revision Version)

Moderator: pauldrach

Post Reply
User avatar
Lew
Posts: 239
Joined: Mon Nov 25, 2024 11:56 am
Location: Florida
Contact:

Greatest Rock Saxophonists (Revision Version)

Post by Lew »

Criteria: Rankings based on acclaim and influence on the style, role and evolution of the sax within rock and the prominence of their work.

Edited By: Sampson
Last Updated: 2015-02-09

https://digitaldreamdoor.com/pages/best ... nists.html

Image
King Curtis

1. King Curtis
2. Sam "The Man" Taylor
3. Lee Allen
4. Maceo Parker
5. Big Jay McNeely
6. Clifford Scott
7. Mike Terry
8. Herb Hardesty
9. Steve Douglas
10. Andrew Love
11. Clarence Clemons
12. Alvin "Red" Tyler
13. "Daddy" Gene Barge
14. Maxwell Davis
15. St. Clair Pinckney
16. Plas Johnson
17. Willis "Gator" Jackson
18. Boots Randolph
19. Hal Singer
20. Gil Bernal
21. Bobby Keys
22. Jimmy Wright
23. Rudy Pompilli
24. David "Fathead" Newman
25. Earl Bostic
26. Red Prysock
27. Junior Walker
28. Doc Kupka
29. Pee Wee Ellis
30. Frank "Floorshow" Culley
31. Lenny Pickett
32. Big Al Sears
33. Charles Chalmers
34. Hank Cosby
35. Buddy Lucas
36. Tom Scott
37. Paul "Hucklebuck" Williams
38. Roland Alphonso
39. Budd Johnson
40. Jesse Powell
41. Floyd Newman
42. Arnett Cobb
43. Jerry Martini
44. Rusty Bryant
45. Wild Bill Moore
46. David Sanborn
47. Chuck Rio (Danny Flores)
48. Tom Archia
49. Paul Bascomb
50. Jimmy Forrest
51. Thomas "Beans" Bowles
52. Cornelius Bumpus
53. Jim Horn
54. Joe Arnold
55. Grady Gaines
56. Jack Schoer
57. Charlie Ferguson
58. Alto Reed
59. Sam Peake
60. Raf Ravenscroft
61. Ace Cannon
62. Michael Brecker
63. Freddie Mitchell
64. Don Myrick
65. David Jackson
66. Chris Wood
67. Joe Houston
68. Dennis "D.T." Thomas
69. Ronald Bell
70. Mel Collins
71. Chuck Higgins
72. Gilbert Caples
73. Dean Fraser
74. Gene Upshaw
75. Kasuka Mafia (Norris Patterson)
76. Red Holloway
77. Leroi Moore
78. Big Jim Wynn
79. Lynn Hope
80. Ernie Watts
81. Sil Austin
82. Oliver Sain
83. Edgar Winter
84. Bob McNeely
85. Bill Justis
86. Buddy Savitt
87. Lester Sterling
88. Phil Kenzie
89. Zach Zackery
90. Mark Rivera
91. James Von Streeter
92. Leon Michels
93. Richie Cannata
94. Harry Haller
95. Lee Thompson
96. Packy Axton
97. Andy MacKay
98. Noble "Thin Man" Watts
99. Jackie Kelso
100. Saxa (Lionel Martin)
Bruce
Posts: 33
Joined: Tue Nov 26, 2024 11:18 pm
Contact:

Re: Greatest Rock Saxophonists

Post by Bruce »

#13 on the list.

Gene Barge, R&B Saxophonist Who Played on Landmark Hits, Dies at 98
Known as Daddy G, he recorded with Jackie Wilson, Chuck Willis and
others, but he was best known for the Gary U.S. Bonds smash “Quarter to
Three.”

By Bill Friskics-Warren
Feb. 4, 2025, 7:11 p.m. ET

Gene Barge, one of the last surviving saxophonists of the golden age of
R&B, whose career ran the gamut of 20th-century Black popular music,
died on Sunday at his home in Chicago. He was 98.

His death was confirmed by his daughter Gina Barge.

Known by the nickname Daddy G, Mr. Barge played on landmark hits of the
rock and soul era, beginning with Chuck Willis’s swinging remake of the
blues standard “C.C. Rider.”

Galvanized by Mr. Barge’s moaning tenor saxophone, “C.C. Rider” reached
No. 1 on the R&B chart in 1957 and stalled just outside the Top 10 on
the pop chart. In 1963, Mr. Barge was featured on Jimmy Soul’s
calypso-derived “If You Wanna Be Happy,” a No. 1 pop and R&B hit.

Mr. Barge also played the wailing tenor part on Fontella Bass’s “Rescue
Me” (1965) and supplied the rhythmic drive, with members of the Motown
house band the Funk Brothers, for Jackie Wilson’s “Your Love Keeps
Lifting Me (Higher and Higher)” (1967). Both records topped the R&B
chart and crossed over to become Top 10 pop hits.

His greatest acclaim, though, came in 1961 with “Quarter to Three,” a
No. 1 pop single recorded with the R&B shouter Gary U.S. Bonds. Hoping
to capitalize on the success of “New Orleans,” his first big hit, Mr.
Bonds created “Quarter to Three” by adding lyrics to “A Night With Daddy
G,” a churning instrumental that Mr. Barge had recently written and
recorded with his band the Church Street Five.

“Oh, don’t you know that I danced/I danced ’til a quarter to 3/With the
help, last night, of Daddy G,” Mr. Bonds sings on the opening chorus.

(“A Night With Daddy G” would prove doubly auspicious when Dion borrowed
its melody for “Runaround Sue,” a finger-snapping wonder that topped the
pop chart in late 1961.)

Despite having the benefit of Mr. Barge’s snaking saxophone runs — and
despite the record’s affinity with the twist dance craze of the day —
“Quarter to Three” was an unlikely sensation. Muffled and lo-fi, it
sounded as if it had been recorded in a bathroom or a stairwell.

“This record is fuzzy, muzzy and distorted,” the British television
producer Jack Good wrote in a 1961 issue of Disc, the popular weekly
music magazine later absorbed into Record Mirror. “According to
present-day technical standards it is appalling. However, for my money,
the disc is not just good, it’s sensational and revolutionary.”

Mr. Good’s assessment of the record proved prescient. An exuberant
fusion of doo-wop, Black gospel and incipient frat rock, “Quarter to
Three” not only inspired the big-beat rock ’n’ roll of the Beatles and
the garage-rock of bands like the Kingsmen and the Sir Douglas Quintet.
It also provided a blueprint for the sax-and-vocal exchanges between
Clarence Clemons and Bruce Springsteen, a rapturous call and response
that came to define the E Street Band, which often performed “Quarter to
Three” in concert.

Breaking into pop music when the saxophone was ascendant (and before it
was supplanted by the electric guitar), Mr. Barge was as distinctive and
versatile a stylist as King Curtis, if less well known. Over six
decades, he played on or produced records by Muddy Waters, the Chi-Lites
and the incendiary Detroit funk band Black Merda. He also toured with
Ray Charles, Bo Diddley and the Rolling Stones.

Sources differ as to how Mr. Barge came to be known as Daddy G. The
sobriquet, though, was already gaining traction before the release of
“Quarter to Three,” when the Philadelphia disc jockey Hy Lit adopted “A
Night With Daddy G” as the theme song for his radio show. Shortly
afterward, the doo-wop group the Dovells paid homage to Mr. Barge on
their 1961 hit “Bristol Stomp,” singing, “We ponied and twisted and we
rocked with Daddy G.”

James Gene Barge Jr. was born on Aug. 9, 1926, in Norfolk, Va., the
oldest of eight children of James and Thelma (Edwards) Barge. His father
played banjo and worked as a welder in the Norfolk Naval Shipyard. His
mother managed the home.

Mr. Barge played clarinet in high school and took up the saxophone only
after his father brought home a waterlogged tenor that he had found on a
torpedo-damaged ship. He was 20 at the time and had just completed two
years in the Army Air Forces.

After graduating from West Virginia State College in 1950 with a degree
in music, he taught high school and pursued music as an avocation. Jazz
was a formative influence, especially the effervescent phrasing of the
great tenor saxophonist Lester Young.

The first recordings Mr. Barge made under his own name were a pair of
instrumentals for Checker, a subsidiary of Chess Records, in 1956.
“Country,” his first single, was a hit along the Eastern Seaboard.

“When Chess heard it, they said, “What the hell is that?” Mr. Barge said
of the record in a 2007 interview with Virginia Living magazine.

“They had never heard a saxophone sound like that before. They even gave
it a word: funk. That was the reputation I got — that Gene Barge could
play funky.”

Around 1960 Mr. Barge began his brief but fruitful association with the
producer Frank Guida, whose Legrand label released “A Night With Daddy
G” and Mr. Bonds’s early singles. Mr. Barge and Mr. Bonds had a second
major hit together with “School Is Out,” which reached the Top 10 in
1961, but enjoyed only modest success after that.

In 1964, as independent record labels with national distribution
increasingly dominated regional markets, Mr. Barge abandoned teaching —
and Norfolk’s small Legrand imprint — and moved to Chicago to work for
Chess Records. While there he played on R&B hits like Little Milton’s
“Grits Ain’t Groceries” and Koko Taylor’s “Wang Dang Doodle” and
produced albums, including Buddy Guy’s acclaimed 1967 effort, “Left My
Blues in San Francisco.”

In the late 1960s, he also directed the musical ensemble of the Chicago
chapter of the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.’s Operation Breadbasket,
an organization headed locally by the Rev. Jesse Jackson.

Mr. Barge later ran the gospel division of Stax Records and, over the
ensuing decades, worked as a freelance musician, producer and arranger,
most notably on Natalie Cole’s Grammy-winning single “Sophisticated Lady
(She’s a Different Lady).” In the late 1970s he took a detour into
acting, working locally in Chicago (he made his screen debut in the
independent 1978 film “Stony Island”) before eventually landing roles in
Hollywood action thrillers like ”Under Siege” (1992) and “The Fugitive”
(1993).

Mr. Barge remained active into the 2000s, serving as a consultant for
Martin Scorsese’s 2003 PBS documentary series “The Blues” and playing on
records like Public Enemy’s “Superman’s Black in the Building” and with
the avant-garde jazz trumpeter Malachi Thompson.

“Gene Barge is the flyest octogenarian I know,” Chuck D of Public Enemy
told Virginia Living in 2007. “To go from Muddy Waters to Public Enemy
is a good trick.”

In addition to his daughter Gina, Mr. Barge is survived by another
daughter, Gail Florence; three siblings, Celestine Bailey, Kim
Williamson and Milton Barge; two grandchildren; and several
great-grandchildren. His wife, Sarah Barge, died in 2008. His first
marriage ended in divorce.

Mr. Barge’s career might not have gotten off to the start it did with
Chuck Willis’s “C.C. Rider” were it not for his patience and good humor.
After playing the grinding riff on the demo that persuaded Ahmet Ertegun
and Jerry Wexler of Atlantic Records to record it as a single, he was
flown to New York for the session, only to find that another saxophonist
had been hired instead.

“Ertegun and Wexler told me they were going to pay me, but they didn’t
want me to play,” Mr. Barge told Virginia Living.

“I went down to the liquor store, man, got me a pint and sat down on the
floor to listen to them. They did 27 takes and weren’t satisfied. So
Chuck said, ‘Look, why don’t you let Gene run down one to get the feel?’
So I ran down one and they said, ‘Hold it, that’s it, you got it. Let’s
cut it.’”
Tim
Posts: 1072
Joined: Sun Dec 08, 2024 8:23 am
Contact:

Re: Greatest Rock Saxophonists (Revision Version)

Post by Tim »

Not really equipped for revising this list musically but figure it would be convenient to list examples of artists these sax players recorded and/or performed with alongside the players themselves.

1. King Curtis (solo; Aretha Franklin; The Coasters)
2. Sam "The Man" Taylor (Big Joe Turner; The Drifters; Chords)
3. Lee Allen (Fats Domino; Lloyd Price; Little Richard)
4. Maceo Parker (James Brown; Parliament; Funkadelic)
5. Big Jay McNeely (solo; Johnny Otis; The Treniers)
6. Clifford Scott (Bill Doggett; Freddie King; James Brown)
7. Mike Terry (The Supremes; Martha & the Vandellas; The Four Tops)
8. Herb Hardesty (Fats Domino; Lloyd Price; Shirley & Lee)
9. Steve Douglas (Duane Eddy; Bob Dylan; The Beach Boys)
10. Andrew Love (Otis Redding; Wilson Pickett; Sam & Dave)
11. Clarence Clemons (Bruce Springsteen; The Grateful Dead; Lady Gaga)
12. Alvin "Red" Tyler (Professor Longhair; Little Richard; Dr. John)
13. "Daddy" Gene Barge (The Church Street Five; Gary U.S. Bonds; Chuck Willis)
14. Maxwell Davis (Percy Mayfield; Peppermint Harris; Little Willie Littlefield)
15. St. Clair Pinckney (James Brown; Parliament; Funkadelic)
16. Plas Johnson (Sam Cooke; The Beach Boys; Ricky Nelson)
17. Willis "Gator" Jackson (solo; Ruth Brown; Bo Diddley)
18. Boots Randolph (solo; Elvis Presley; Roy Orbison)
19. Hal Singer (solo; The Orioles; Charles Brown)
20. Gil Bernal (The Coasters; The Robins; Duane Eddy)
21. Bobby Keys (The Rolling Stones; John Lennon; Joe Cocker)
22. Jimmy Wright (Frankie Lymon & the Teenagers; James Brown; Hank Ballard & the Midnighters)
23. Rudy Pompilli (Bill Haley & His Comets; The Treniers)
24. David "Fathead" Newman (solo; Ray Charles; Aretha Franklin)
25. Earl Bostic (solo; Paul Williams; Little Esther Phillips)
26. Red Prysock (Bill Doggett; James Brown; Wynonie Harris)
27. Junior Walker (Junior Walker & the All Stars; Aretha Franklin; Foreigner)
28. Doc Kupka (Tower of Power; Heart; Elton John)
29. Pee Wee Ellis (James Brown; Van Morrison, The Meters)
30. Frank "Floorshow" Culley (solo; Fats Domino; Ruth Brown)
31. Lenny Pickett (Tower of Power; Graham Central Station; The Pointer Sisters)
32. Big Al Sears (solo; Wynonie Harris; Bill Haley & His Comets)
33. Charles Chalmers (Jerry Lee Lewis; Aretha Franklin; Al Green)
34. Hank Cosby (Stevie Wonder; Smokey Robinson & The Miracles; Diana Ross & the Supremes)
35. Buddy Lucas (Little Willie John; Dion and the Belmonts; Jimmy Smith)
36. Tom Scott (The Blues Brothers; L.A. Express; Paul McCartney)
37. Paul "Hucklebuck" Williams (solo; The Coasters; Big Joe Turner)
38. Roland Alphonso (The Skatalites; Bob Marley & the Wailers, Jimmy Cliff)
39. Budd Johnson (solo; Ruth Brown; Big Joe Turner)
40. Jesse Powell (Champion Jack Dupree; Joe Tex; Sam Cooke)
41. Floyd Newman (Otis Redding; Booker T & the M.G.'s; Wilson Pickett)
42. Arnett Cobb (solo; Ruth Brown; Eddie "Cleanhead" Vinson)
43. Jerry Martini (Sly and the Family Stone; Bobby Womack; Rose Royce)
44. Rusty Bryant (solo; Boogaloo Joe Jones; Johnny "Hammond" Smith)
45. Wild Bill Moore (solo; The Supremes; Marvin Gaye)
46. David Sanborn (solo; David Bowie; Stevie Wonder)
47. Chuck Rio (Danny Flores) (solo; The Champs)
48. Tom Archia (Wynonie Harris; Illinois Jacquet; Dinah Washington)
49. Paul Bascomb (solo)
50. Jimmy Forrest (solo)
51. Thomas "Beans" Bowles (The Supremes; Martha & the Vandellas; Chuck Berry)
52. Cornelius Bumpus (Bobby Freeman; The Doobie Brothers; Steely Dan)
53. Jim Horn (Duane Eddy; The 5th Dimension; George Harrison)
54. Joe Arnold (Otis Redding; Clarence Carter; The Mar Keys)
55. Grady Gaines (Little Richard; Sam Cooke; Curtis Mayfield)
56. Jack Schoer (Van Morrison; The Caledonia Soul Orchestra; Paul Simon)
57. Charlie Ferguson (The “5” Royales; Arnett Cobb; Jimmy Liggins)
58. Alto Reed (Bob Seger & the Silver Bullet Band; Foghat; Grand Funk Railroad)
59. Sam Peake (solo; Evelyn "Champagne" King; Patti LaBelle)
60. Raf Ravenscroft (Gerry Rafferty; Pink Floyd; Marvin Gaye)
61. Ace Cannon (solo; Bill Black Combo)
62. Michael Brecker (Brecker Brothers; Billy Joel; James Taylor)
63. Freddie Mitchell (solo; LaVern Baker; Alan Freed)
64. Don Myrick (Earth, Wind & Fire; Phil Collins; The Emotions)
65. David Jackson (Van der Graaf Generator; Peter Hammill; Peter Gabriel)
66. Chris Wood (Traffic; The Jimi Hendrix Experience; Free)
67. Joe Houston (solo; Big Joe Turner; Wynonie Harris)
68. Dennis "D.T." Thomas (Kool & the Gang)
69. Ronald Bell (Kool & the Gang)
70. Mel Collins (King Crimson; Camel; Alexis Korner)
71. Chuck Higgins (solo; The Orioles)
72. Gilbert Caples (Otis Redding; Wilson Pickett; Bobby "Blue" Bland)
73. Dean Fraser (solo; Dennis Brown; Sly & Robbie)
74. Gene Upshaw (The Del-Vikings)
75. Kasuka Mafia (Norris Patterson) (The Temptations; Martha & the Vandellas; Marvin Gaye and Tammi Terrell)
76. Red Holloway (solo; Gene Ammons; Jack McDuff)
77. LeRoi Moore (Dave Matthews Band)
78. Big Jim Wynn (solo; Johnny Otis; Etta James)
79. Lynn Hope (solo)
80. Ernie Watts (Marvin Gaye; Barry White; Carole King)
81. Sil Austin (solo; Cootie Williams; Tiny Bradshaw)
82. Oliver Sain (solo; Little Milton; Ike Turner's Kings of Rhythm)
83. Edgar Winter (The Edgar Winter Group; Tina Turner; David Lee Roth)
84. Bob McNeely (Big Jay McNeely; Johnny Otis; Z. Z. Hill)
85. Bill Justis (solo)
86. Buddy Savitt (Hank Ballard; Chubby Checker; Bobby Rydell)
87. Lester Sterling (solo; The Skatalites; Byron Lee & the Dragonaires)
88. Phil Kenzie (The Beatles; Eagles; Al Stewart)
89. Zach Zackery (MFSB; Patti LaBelle; Teddy Pendergrass)
90. Mark Rivera (Billy Joel; Hall & Oates; Peter Gabriel)
91. James Von Streeter (Johnny Otis)
92. Leon Michels (El Michels Affair; Lee Fields & The Expressions; Menahan Street Band)
93. Richie Cannata (Billy Joel; The Beach Boys; Al Jardine)
94. Harry Haller (The Viscounts)
95. Lee Thompson (Madness)
96. Packy Axton (The Mar-Keys; The Packers; Booker T. & the M.G.'s)
97. Andy Mackay (Roxy Music; The Explorers; Brian Eno)
98. Noble "Thin Man" Watts (Lionel Hampton; Paul "Hucklebuck" Williams; Dinah Washington)
99. Jackie Kelso (Johnny Otis; Gene Vincent and His Blue Caps; Johnny Rivers)
100. Saxa (Lionel Martin) (The English Beat)
Last edited by Tim on Thu Apr 09, 2026 6:05 am, edited 3 times in total.
Fido
Posts: 285
Joined: Tue Nov 26, 2024 11:19 am
Contact:

Re: Greatest Rock Saxophonists (Revision Version)

Post by Fido »

That's a great addition
Tim
Posts: 1072
Joined: Sun Dec 08, 2024 8:23 am
Contact:

Re: Greatest Rock Saxophonists (Revision Version)

Post by Tim »

Some other rock (or rock-adjacent) sax players:

Harold Battiste (solo; Sam Cooke; Dr John)
Steve Berlin (Los Lobos; Top Jimmy & the Rhythm Pigs; The Blasters)
David Bowie (solo; Tin Machine)
Sam Butera (solo; Louis Prima; Keely Smith)
Jimmy Cavallo (The Jimmy Cavallo Quartet; Fats Domino; Big Joe Turner)
Eddie Chamblee (solo; Lionel Hampton; Dinah Washington)
Eddie "Lockjaw" Davis (solo; Cootie Williams; Lucky Millinder)
Candy Dulfer (solo; Madonna; Dave Stewart)
Molly Duncan (Average White Band; Ray Charles; Tom Petty)
Steve Gregory (George Michael; Fleetwood Mac; The Rolling Stones)
"Blind" John Hart (Clifton Chenier And His Red Hot Louisiana Band; Lynn August & The Hot August Knights)
John Helliwell (Supertramp; The Alan Bown Set; Pink Floyd)
Bull Moose Jackson (solo; Lucky Millinder)
Little Willie Jackson (solo; Joe Liggins; The Honeydrippers)
Illinois Jacquet (solo; Lionel Hampton)
Louis Jordan (Louis Jordan & His Tympany Five)
Rahsaan Roland Kirk (solo)
Roger "Chrome Dome" Lewis (Dirty Dozen Brass Band; Elvis Costello; Widespread Panic)
Fred Lipsius (Blood, Sweat & Tears)
Joe Lutcher (solo)
Stuart Matthewman (Sade)
Jack McVea (solo; Lionel Hampton)
Freddie "Taxi" Mitchell (Hen Gates) (solo)
Steve Norman (Spandau Ballet)
Walter Parazaider (Chicago)
Dick Parry (Pink Floyd; J. J. Jackson; Bloodstone)
Red Price (Lord Rockingham's XI; The Red Price Combo; Billy Fury and the Blue Flames)
Ronnie Ross (solo; Lou Reed; Matt Bianco)
Stephen Singleton (ABC)
Joe Thomas (solo)
Lionel Torrence (Prevost) (Clifton Chenier; Clarence Garlow; Roscoe Gordon)
Eddie “Cleanhead” Vinson (solo)
Post Reply

Return to “Other Instruments”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests