Movie Directors' Top Films

[Tim]

Think this breakdown slightly favors Gentlemen Prefer Blondes even though Sergeant York is ranked higher on the 1940s list (#65) than Gentlemen Prefer Blondes on the 1950s list (#87).

[pauldrach]

Think this breakdown slightly favors Gentlemen Prefer Blondes even though Sergeant York is ranked higher on the 1940s list (#65) than Gentlemen Prefer Blondes on the 1950s list (#87).

How so? With acclaim going to SY, popularity about a draw and influence going to GPB, this seems to be a toss-up. I'm ok with giving the edge to GPB though if we think the influence win is bigger than the acclaim one.

[ManPerson]

I'd say the influence win is larger than the win in acclaim.

[pauldrach]

I did swap.

[ManPerson]

Oh, I didn't notice that. Lists all look good now.